Our study of Colorado government, big industry, and grass roots
entrepreneurs shows the success of local self-reliance. We believe lessons
learned are applicable nationally.
Clearly the money and political clout is found at the top. However
considerable technology innovation and insight into needs of local communities
is found at the grass roots. It seems that there is a great disconnect
between the two. A major goal of this study is to help bridge the gap
between them and to give those at the top reason to think that it could
be in everyone's long term interest to pay careful attention to the
grass roots. Our report should be useful to corporate strategists and
planners, and to the same people at the state and local government
and educational level as power shifts away from Washington. We are considering
further such studies in Tennessee, Washington state and possibly Massachusetts.
During the early part of December 1994 we traveled over 1000 miles
within Colorado and interviewed over two dozen people ranging from the
Lieutenant Governor; to several school teachers; to one of the key implementors
of the new US West business strategy known as Community of Interest
Networks (COINS).
Our report tells five stories. First we summarize what is taking place
in Colorado at the state level and the high end in Denver and in Boulder.
This story covers Colorado Supernet, the state level ISP, and Colorado's
innovative state library network. It looks at US West's ATM trials in
Boulder and at the Boulder Valley Community network. It begins with
a look at the Lieutenant Governor's State Telecommunications Task force.
This first part is generally a description of and commentary on efforts
from the top - some of which have not yet learned all the insights of
bottom up planning.
The second part offers a more detailed look at a particular top down
effort - the US West Teacher Network. The third examines Dave Hughes'
HiCom System and decentralized, bottom-up philosophy. The fourth is
a case study of the grass roots low cost technology innovation spear-headed
by Dave Hughes in the San Luis Valley of Colorado. The fifth and most
important is the bottom up, Community of Interest Network, learning
process at US West as told to us by AJ Remsing.
We learned that while the state government was generally trying to
do the right thing, it is missing some very innovative and cost effective
grass roots strategies developed not at large corporations but rather
at local electronic cottages. We observed one such grass roots strategist
Dave Hughes who having been largely passed over from foundation grants,
has developed a $6,000 Internet in a suitcase. It now appears that several
school systems Colorado's remote and beautiful San Luis Valley have
been able to purchase these machines. With Hughes shaving the cost of
Internet connections by an order of magnitude having up to sixteen simultaneous
users multiplexed out a single serial port via a V-Fast dial-up slip-connection
to Colorado Supernet, the Valley is in the process of going on-line
WITHOUT state, federal or foundation aid.
In another equally important development AJ REMSING, a former US West
Educational Markets manager startled some observers in October by stating
that US West had concluded that top down implementation of National
Information Infrastructure simply would not work. Indeed that US West
was convinced that bottom up was the only way to proceed. Our study
concludes with a 6,000 word interview with AJ Remsing in which she tells
us in detail how the COINS program was developed within US West. COINS
embraces a marketing methodology of talking applications not technology;
identifying local and national champions for and application; forming
necessary consortia, sometimes even with competitors, to bring the most
cost effective resources to bear on the application; finding an anchor
tenant for the application; looking for policy solutions if there are
application policy problems standing in the way of success; and seeing
that the local customer has buy-in ownership and control over the design
and development process. Solving LOCAL problems at the local
level.
We think that such a change in thought process for such a large corporation
is significant and praise worthy - especially when compared to approaches
by MCI and Microsoft to roll out industrial age, mass produced NATIONAL
level programs where the variety of options available to individual
customers is either very small or non existent. National Information
Infrastructure should be seen as LOCAL information infrastructure, that,
if widely enough seeded, will eventually become national. To this end
we think it highly significant that the systems being rolled out by
Hughes in Colorado (since they can be administered by teachers as sys-ops)
hold out the possibility of schools themselves becoming service providers,
renting Web pages and offering local consulting. If schools do this
then they actually become mechanisms for development of community information
infrastructure. Such infrastructure will be infinitely more attractive
at the psychological and economic level than any great conveyor belts
in the sky offered by Bill Gates.
US West, beset by enormous consumer dissatisfaction within its serving
area is learning. Northern Telecom has implemented its own bottom up
strategy. Signs exist that the same bottom up strategy may be spreading
to Jones InterCable. While Gore, as a national champion has been important
in raising consciousness, the talk coming out of Washington has created
what we believe to be a hype-filled speculative bubble. There is substance
beneath the hype. Our report shows the substance in one pivotal state
- Colorado in great detail.
| San Luis Valley History According to Dave Hughes |
37 |
| Ken Russel on the Econimic History of the San Luis Valley |
39 |
| Debbie Felmlee - Schoolboard Member and Local Champion for Bringing
the Internet to Center |
41 |
| Gary Kidd - School Superintendent |
43 |
| Telecommunications & Culture - Clarice Jones School Board Member
and Dave Hughes |
45 |
| Terri Day - Science Teacher |
46 |
| Veronica Vasquez - the Elementary School Principal and Vivian Mondragon
- Business Teacher and Coordinator High School Computer Lab |
47 |
| Noel Dunne: Grass Roots Economic Development in Alamosa
| 48 |
| Why Denver May be Irrelevant |
51 |
| Post Script to Our Visit by Dave Hughes |
52 |
| Manufacturing Pcs in the Valley? |
53 |